Your Shape Fitness Evolved For Xbox 360 And Kinect: A Review

by · 17 comments

I mentioned last week that I had purchased the new peripheral for the Xbox 360, the Kinect. The Kinect is basically a motion sensing and tracking device that allows you to control your video games without holding a controller in your hands. To me it’s one of the most exciting advancements in gaming technology in years, probably since the Wii came out with the motion tracking Wiimote.

While the Kinect is priced a bit on the high side ($150), after having a week or so with the device I have to say that I’ve been thoroughly impressed and I feel like it was worth it for me. In my few tests so far in using the device it has been extremely accurate in sensing my motion, and the only real glitches I’ve seen are due to the fact that my play area probably isn’t large enough. That is the biggest con I’ve found of the device so far – that the Kinect needs you to have a play area 8×8 feet or larger to really enjoy it to it’s full potential.

So far I’ve got two games that I’ve been able to test out, Kinect Adventures (which comes with the Kinect), and Your Shape: Fitness Evolved – a fitness title that aims to take full advantage of the Kinect’s motion sensing capabilities, and really take the fitness video game genre to a new level. Today I’m going to do an initial review of Your Shape: Fitness Evolved.

Your Shape Fitness Evolved

Before we get too far into the review, let’s start with a quick look at what Your Shape is supposed to be from the Amazon.com description:

Your Shape Fitness Evolved is a fitness-simulation game for Xbox 360 that is designed to deliver a 3D, controller-free fitness simulation experience like no other. Built around the camera, depth sensors and multi-array microphone of the Microsoft Kinect sensor peripheral,* the game allows for real-time motion capture of the players movements, facial recognition and both voice and interactive menu commands. This combined with Ubisoft’s Player Projection Technology, which enables the Kinect sensor to track up to a million data points on the player’s body, results in low lag and total player immersion in what is destined to be the most challenging fitness-simulation game to date. Additional features include: in-game instructors, multiple exercise classes, workouts created by real experts, progress tracking and multiplayer support.

So Your Shape aims to give the player a totally immersive experience where they’re able to actually be in the game, not be distracted by feeling like the game isn’t a real workout and be challenged by a variety of workouts, classes and mini-games.

For me the game so far has done that – when I’m playing it I feel like I’m really at the gym taking a class or getting a one-on-one personal training session. To me it’s probably the only fitness video game (or video) that I’ve done that makes me feel like I’m actually getting a tough workout, the right way. Because of the Kinect sensor, the game also is able to give you correction and make you feel almost like you’re actually working out with a real instructor!

So let’s jump in and talk about what you’ll find in this product.

Playing The Game

When you launch the game for the first time, the first thing it will do is do a quick scan of you to figure out how tall you are, your body proportions and then ask you some simple questions as far as your age, weight and a couple of other data points.  Based off of what you answer – and the body scan, a somewhat personalized workout plan will be created for you.

They say the camera adds 10 pounds, and Kinect has two cameras. So when Ubisoft’s upcoming Kinect title Your Shape: Fitness Evolved put a somewhat stout-looking projection of me on the screen, I shouldn’t have been surprised—especially given that the game’s success depends on players wanting to melt away those love handles (source)

Depending on what your goals are as well you can choose a variety of programs tailored to your needs.  Just had a baby?  Choose a program tailored to new moms.  Trying to drop some weight?  Choose the weight loss regimen.   Toning up?  Choose the toning program.

Menu Systems Very Intuitive

While I was beginning this process the first thing that I noticed was that the menu system for the game is very intuitive.  Basically, the Kinect sensor camera recognizes you, scans you as you stand there and inserts a full body image of you in the game.  Then as you stand there in game if you reach your arms out you are able to choose different menu options with your hand outstretched, and once you’ve chosen something it always asks you to confirm.

I wasn’t sure how well this was going to work when reading about it online, and whether or not there was going to be a lot of lag from when you do something to when it happens on screen.  I have to say I noticed very little if any lag in this game.   I played a couple of other demos, and kinect adventures – and Your  Shape was by far the most responsive of the games I’ve tried so far.

The menus were very easy to use, and after doing it a few times I found I was controlling the game and menus with little or no thought to it. It just works very well in my opinion.

Workout Options

After being scanned the first time, every time after that you’ll be logged into the game automatically, and the in game hostess will welcome you back  with a “good evening” or “good morning”.    Once you’re in the main menu you can do a variety of different things.  First, you’ll see a customized home screen for you, showing how many calories you’ve burned so far and any challenges you’ve got pending with other users.  You can also change your in game appearance or view any news or updates by simply stepping on one of two small  circles in your play area on screen.  If you don’t want to do any of those things, you can simply begin your workout by choosing either “personal training”, “gym games” or

Personal Training

One of the first options you have in-game is to do the personal training – customized training sessions that are tailored to your fitness level and fitness goals that you chose when you first signed on.  To me this is the heart of the game.  For me I chose a weight loss goal and started right in with the cardio workouts.

You can either let the game guide you through workouts, or choose a specific one that you want to do. When choosing workouts it will tell you what it is, how long it takes, and how advanced the workout is.

The first one I chose was a cardio workout.  The clock starts and the game begins by showing you how to do a couple of the moves that will be included in the workout.  The Kinect sensor tracks you and shows you on-screen – and will tell you when you’re not doing the exercise right.   Think you’re going to dog it when working out?  Think again!  The game will recognize when you’re not lifting your legs high enough, or your arms aren’t going up all the way, and will tell you to pick it up and improve.  For example, I was doing lunges at one point, and getting tired.   I started not dipping close enough to the ground. The game recongized that and told me to dip lower.  I did, and felt the burn!

The first couple of cardio workouts that I did were up to an intensity level for me right now (where I’m out of shape) where I felt challenged, but not like I was going to fall over and die. While you’re working out the game tracks the number of calories you should be burning – and will keep track of that for you every time you workout.  While I can’t vouch for how accurate that part of it is (there is some debate about that), I can tell you it’s a useful yardstick for yourself when working out.

The day after doing the cardio workouts I did a brief Men’s Health upper body weights workout (there are several Men’s Health and Women’s Health sponsored workouts in the game).  The weights workout was effective as well, and I found myself getting a great workout, while getting useful feedback from the game when my form wasn’t up to par.  To me, the feedback you get from the game is extremely helpful because it helps you to get a better workout, all while having better form than you might otherwise have had.

I’ve only been doing the personal training workouts for about 3 days now, but so far I’ve been pretty impressed with how much of a workout I feel like I’m getting, and how effectively the game uses the Kinect sensor to improve your workouts.

Gym Games

Another part of the game that can be fun, although I haven’t found it to be overly exerting, is the gym games.   You may have seen some of the gym games on the commercial, especially the virtual smash game (show below)

The games found in the title include:

  • Virtual smash:  In this game you are trying to punch and kick as many blocks with your hands, knees and feet as you can before the time runs out.  In more advanced levels you’ll also need to avoid swinging pendulums.
  • Light race:  You stand in a circle and have to have fancy footwork in order to copy the pattern of lights appearing on the circle around you.  Reminds me of that old handheld game where you hit the buttons in the same pattern the game does, or you’re out.
  • Loop-a-hoop:  You do the hula hoop for a set period of time and try to get the balls lifted and out the hole in the ceiling based on the intensity of your hula-hooping.
  • Stack em up:  You hold your arms in the air and catch blocks and balls on a platform as fast as you can, and dump them into holes in the floor when they open up to get points.

The games can all be played with anywhere from 1 to 4 players, one player at a time.  They’re fun, but I can’t see myself playing these games over and over unless we had others over at the house and needed some laughs.

Fitness Classes

There are also currently two fitness classes that you can take in-game.  Yoga training and cardio boxing.

So far I’ve taken one of each class, and they do what they’re supposed to. The yoga class takes you through a progression of yoga moves over the time period, scoring you on how well you do. I’m not a big yoga guy so I can’t see myself doing this too often. I had heard it suggested that you do a yoga routine after working out as a cool-down, and i can see how that might work well, that’s how I did it this time.

The cardio boxing is more enjoyable for me. I did this routine the other day and it does give you a good workout.  My only thing is that I have a hard time following along sometimes – although part of the great thing about this game is that it helps you to fix what you’re doing wrong.   You can see yourself on-screen  and compare to the instructor – and the game tells you what you’re doing wrong.  I love that.

Conclusion

After playing Your Shape: Fitness Evolved for the past few days, I’ve been very impressed with the game, and would highly recommend it to anyone.  Among the high points.

  • Great utilization of Kinect:  The game’s use of the Kinect sensor in the game’s menus, workouts and games is done really well. The menus are responsive, there is hardly any lag, and it really does give you an immersive experience.   I especially love how the game gives you feedback and helps correct you when you’re not doing the exercises correctly.
  • You will break a sweat:  While the novelty of Kinect will certainly sell the game, the fact that the workouts actually make you sweat will keep you coming back.
  • Good variety of workouts: There are a good variety of workouts that will keep you entertained for weeks to come.
  • It’s fun!:  The game is just plain fun – never mind the fact that you’re getting a good workout!

The game isn’t without it’s faults.  Some cons:

  • You need a large play area:  One of the downsides for the game is that you need a pretty big area to play the game in, in order for it to track you correctly.
  • Environment is kinda plain sometimes: The white backgrounds on the game can be kind of plain and vanilla at times.  more colorful backgrounds might have been nice.
  • Number of workouts isn’t exhaustive:  Although the game does come with quite a few workouts, the game isn’t exhaustive.  They do plan on releasing more as downloadable content, however.

I’m loving Your Shape: Fitness Evolved so far, and look forward to dropping some pounds using it over the next few months!

Get more details and your copy of Your Shape: Fitness Evolved at Amazon.com

Have you tried out Your Shape: Fitness Evolved?  What was your experience?   Considering getting the game? What’s holding you back? Tell us your thoughts in the comments.


There are affiliate links in this post. If you purchase something through my link, I will receive a small commission. Thanks in advance if you do!



{ 12 comments… read them below or add one }

will November 18, 2010 at 10:34 am

Enjoyed your review. I have the product and i would have to agree 100% on everything you say. I would like to see a similar review on the EA Active2.

Reply

Peter November 18, 2010 at 11:04 am

Thanks for your comments. I wouldn’t mind doing a review of EA Active 2, I just don’t want to shell out another $100 for that game! Maybe someone will see this review and offer me a free review copy. ;)

Reply

Brian Costelloe November 21, 2010 at 7:33 pm

I have been a beta tester for the Kinect so some months now so I’ve been lucky enough to put the sensor unit through it’s paces. But having only access to only three rather limited titles has left me wanting more! Kinect Sports was one of the test games I’m really impressed with. But these fitness titles are where the Kinect really will shine. Which leaves me in the same position as you. I like the idea of the heart monitor for the EA title but the Ubi Soft project looks more in depth than the rest. Have you had a chance to make any comparisons?

Reply

Jeff November 22, 2010 at 7:43 pm

Hey – what sort of weights would I want/need if I wanted to use this for a work out, mostly focussing on weight loss? I moved and there isn’t really a gym I want to go to in the area and I think this could work for me, but I want to know what I need beyond the Kinect, the XBOX and the game.

Reply

Peter November 22, 2010 at 11:27 pm

right now i’m just using a pair of 10 pound weights, so if you’ve got some dumbbells to use, that might work. Personally I’ve only been doing the “Men’s Health” upper body weight workout so far, and the 10 pound weights are fine for me right now. If you’re in better shape, some heavier weights might work. I think the game suggests starting out with 5 lb weights though – and shows weights in varying sizes up to like 25 lbs.

Reply

Nancy Naigle November 28, 2010 at 8:32 am

Thanks for the recap. I just purchased my Fitness Evolved yesterday. I got through the scan and a couple of the gym games. Your run down has given me a good idea of what to look for and do next. I was surprised there is no real detailed booklet of all the cool options … but hey, you did that for me :) Thanks!!! Good luck with your weight loss plan .. I’m on the same journey.
Nan

Reply

dave January 17, 2011 at 2:22 pm

Hey Peter,

I’m finding it annoying that if you change your personal training activity, say from “break a sweat” to a MH weight loss program, it resets the number of classes you’ve taken. So i do 3 break a sweats over a 4 day period, then do a MH one, and when i select break a sweat again, i’ve got to start at 1 again. I’ve only just started playing, and you’ve had it a lot longer than me, as you progress through the number of workouts in a series, does the program change? I cant see me wanting to do 12 lots of the break a sweat if it’s only gonna make me do the same 6 exercises every time!

thanks!

Dave

Reply

Peter January 17, 2011 at 3:00 pm

Dave, I just discovered this as well over the weekend, and I will agree it’s annoying. I was over half way through the Men’s Health sleeve busting arms workout personal training session (7 workouts in), and then decided to try a cardio program to break things up. Then I went back to Men’s Health – and poof! all my progress was gone, and I had to start over! ugh. that is frustrating, I hope they fix that in a future update. Time to go comment on their facebook page!

Reply

John January 31, 2011 at 6:19 pm

I found a work-around for the annoying issue with losing your progress: Create a profile for “strength training” and one for “cardio”. Then you can flip flop between the two profiles. This doesn’t fix the issue but at least you can get a good workout.

However, I seriously doubt it matters. The programs do not appear to change at all as you progress. I am almost done with “Toned Body” and nothing has changed. Has anyone experienced any change in any program as you progress?

My hunch is they rushed the release of this with little or NO testing. They should dismiss their testing staff for sure. Time for some turnover. I wish they could fix this! I’d pay money to have this thing work as intended!!!

Oh, and the online portal is broken as well on my account. I completed one goal and it exploded. Nice Reward.

Reply

Pam Ocque January 23, 2012 at 6:51 pm

HI John,

My husband has just started using Your Shape Fitness Evolved and has noticed a very big bug….or maybe he’s doing something wrong. Every time he uses the game, it starts him back at the beginning where he has to do the fitness test. He has played this 3 times and he’s getting discouraged. What is he doing wrong? It doesn’t give him the option to save the fitness test as far as we can see. Any help would be appreciated. Thank you!

Reply

Peter January 23, 2012 at 8:55 pm

I’m not sure why it would do that, I’ve never had that happen. It saved it just fine for me. Sorry I don’t know how to help you on this one.

Reply

Chad April 7, 2014 at 10:43 pm

I enjoy the Your Shape program myself. It has lots of intense as well as interesting work outs. It has the ability to track your progress and make recommendations on works.

Problem I’m having is that I cancelled my Xbox live subscription and it doesn’t save anything. I also have to listen to the tutorial every time I load the game. So I guess, on less anyone has a solution, you have to buy the game plus add $10.00 a month or $59.99 a year. And I don’t think Xbox One will be supporting this game and I read a while back Microsoft will support Xbox 360 until 2016.

Reply

Leave a Comment

{ 5 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: